Oteri's Italian Bakery

Let me tell you something I had this crazy grand idea for my baby shower cake and I reached out to so many different private bakers and bakeries and nobody really could see my vision the way I saw it or their pricing was ridiculous when I tell you I reached out to Oteris they gave me a quote. I placed a deposit and up until the day of the baby shower. I was so nervous. I did not know what to expect. I didn’t know if they were gonna be able to execute it right on the nose And the results were absolutely astonishing. The cake was gorgeous. The details were exactly on point everybody at the baby shower was so stunned by how amazing this cake was and on top of that it tasted amazing. I was so happy with my cake. 10 out of 10 I highly recommend

My daughter was in love with her cake! Not only did it look just like the picture, it tasted good too. We went with the pound cake and it was delicious.

The cake was great. Absolutely delicious and super creative. I loved it. They listened to exactly what I wanted and perfected it. 10/10 experience. I Would definitely recommend!

The cake I ordered for my bf birthday party tasted and looked amazing 😍 by the end of the party the cake was gone and I don't even like cake. I ordered a Hennessy cake vanilla with butter cream filling 🤤 We will be ordering from Oteri's Italian Bakery again!!! Best cake I've ever ate. The customer service was amazing and the price for the cake was fair. My family would order cakes from Oteri's since I was young. Just keeping the traditions going. I would definitely recommend Oteri's.

I ordered my birthday cake from here and it turned out amazing. For the most part, I had an amazing experience with the service except for the day before pick up when I was requesting an early pick up. The first person did not give me an answer and just said it will be ready at the ordered pick up time. But she was actually rude (she sounded overwhelmed and irritated) and the next person was much kinder and was very honest about when it would be ready. Cake was lovely, and I’d order a cake from here again!

Purchased a customized cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was EVERYTHING and my daughter LOVED IT!! I have been a patron of Oteri’s on 5th St since middle school and always go to them for specialty cakes…THEY NEVER MISS!! Thanks Oteri’s for helping to make my daughter’s birthday memorable!

Thank you so much Oteri’s bakery for making my son’s birthday even more awesome by making his favorite character cake. His cake was so amazing. I almost cried with excitement. I will definitely use your services for the next upcoming events. I highly recommend Oteri’s bakery for all of your special occasions or events. Thank you again! 😊

I placed the online order sent them a picture, of what I was looking for. It's was a gift for my daughter‘s 14th birthday. They executed the picture to a Tee. sup piercing my expectationsbetter than what I expected. From the design to the flavor. Everything was immaculate. I appreciate them so much for making my daughters day so special.

I needed a quick order of cookies for my grandson birthday and was able to get them within the days which was pretty quick. The cookies tasted delicious. Exceeded my expectations!!

My husband and I have been ordering birthday cakes from this bakery for years and they never disappoint. The service is professional and friendly always and the cake is always fresh and tasty and designed to our liking. I am always very happy with my orders. Never had a problem with this business.