From our family to your family with love!OUR LOCATIONS

Our Menu

Cakes Available Daily

Our wonderful cakes have been baked fresh on premises daily, since great-grandparents Gaetano and Sarah baked and sold them right out of their home kitchen! Today, we have a wide variety of special occasion cakes available everyday right here in our store, where you can walk in and purchase them on the spot without preordering. For those with something more personal in mind, we will make any style cake in any design you create. Just send us a photo or a design idea and we will recreate it on a custom made cake in the flavor of your choice. Be creative! There's nothing Oteri's can't whip up for you!

Ring Cake ~ Caramel Apple

A moist coffee cake with apples and cinnamon, topped strudel crumb and icing.

Banana Royal Chocolate Cake

Banana Royal Chocolate Cake

Rich chocolate cake filled with fresh strawberries, bananas and whipped cream.

Black Forrest Cake

Rich, dark chocolate cake, filled with our homemade cherry filling, iced with fresh whipped cream and finished with chocolate shavings around the sides.

Butter Cake

Sweet dough with a creamy buttery topping. It melts in your mouth.

Cannoli Cake

An Oteri's original! This unique cake begins with our original recipe Oteri's sponge cake.  We fill the sponge cake with the same sweet ricotta cheese used in our famous cannoli. We ice it with whipp
Read More

Carrot Cake

This cake boasts fresh grated carrots and our unique combination of spices and finished with velvety cream cheese icing.

Cheese Cake Sugar Free

Our Famous New York Style Cheese Cake - now available SUGAR FREE!    You can now order this item online:  Read More

Chocolate Mousse Cake

A Rich, dark chocolate cake filled with raspberry, decorated with chocolate mousse and finished with chocolate ganache topping.

Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake

Rich, dark chocolate cake filled with fresh strawberries and whipped cream and topped with chocolate ganache and whipped cream.

Italian Rum Cake

Our famous Italian rum cake is made in three mouth-watering layers from our original sponge cake recipe. Each layer is soaked in our homemade rum punch, stacked and filled with our vanilla and chocola
Read More

Limoncello Cake

Layers of sponge cake soaked in Limon cello liqueur, with a lemon filling and whipped cream topping.

Loaf Cake Sugar Free

Our mouth watering load cake -now available  SUGAR FREE!

Loaf Cake ~ Chocolate Chip ~ 1lb

Our loaf cakes are made from our famous old-fashioned butter pound cake recipe. Our Chocolate Chip Loaf Cake has delicious chocolate chips inside and out.

Loaf Cake ~ Chocolate Chocolate ~ 1lb

This is a chocolate lovers delight! Made from our famous old-fashioned butter pound cake recipe. And all chocolate, chocolate, chocolate inside and out!

Loaf Cake ~ Marble ~ 1lb

This loaf cake is marble from the inside out including the delicious icing. Our loaf cakes are made from our famous old-fashioned butter pound cake recipe.

Loaf Cake ~ Old Fashioned with Vanilla Icing ~ 1lb

Our loaf cakes are made from our famous old-fashioned butter pound cake recipe. The vanilla icing on this load cake is "what icing on the cake" is all about!

Loaf Cake ~ Raspberry Swirl ~ 1lb

Swirl icing over our famous old-fashioned butter pound cake recipe with raspberry swirl . A combination that will put a smile on your face as the flavor tickles your taste buds.

Oreo Cookie Cake

Moist dark chocolate cake filled and decorated with a butter cream cookie filling.

Pineapple Upside-down Cake

Made from our pineapple flavored layer cake then topped with fresh pineapples and a sugar honey glaze.

Raspberry Coffee Cake Ring

A moist coffee cake with embedded swirls of raspberry preserves.

Ring Cake ~ Black Forrest Coffee

Chocolate coffee cake with cherries and a fudge topping.

Ring Cake ~ Blueberry Coffee

Coffee cake baked with fresh blueberries, with a strudel topping.

Shadow Cake

A layer each of vanilla cake and chocolate cake, with butter cream filling and drizzled icing and poured ganache dripping down.

Strawberry New York Cheese Cake with Whipped Cream

Creamy, rich New York-style cheesecake topped with fresh strawberries and whipped cream.

Strawberry Shortcake

One of our specialties, our Strawberry Shortcake is a holiday favorite. We begin with classic sponge cake made from our own original recipe, fill with fresh strawberries and real whipped cream. Topped
Read More


Vanilla Coconut Custard

Tropical Fruit Cream Cake

Layers of sponge cake, filled with a smooth vanilla custard and topped with a thin layer of raspberry and seasonal fresh fruit soaked in a sweet glaze.

Tropical Fruit New York Cheese Cake

Our famous creamy New York-Style Cheesecake, topped with the freshest seasonal fruits and finished with a sweet glaze over the fruit.  Available is 7 or 10 inch sizes.